Sunday, June 13, 2021

Saints and viruses are not to be married

 

It was the beginning of the Pandemic and people were getting familiar with the new lockdown normal. A protestant pastor had the bold idea to protect his community by praying for the safety of every single parishioner. He took his commitment seriously and not a single day passed by without his earnest prayers that were meant to protect the faithful believers (i.e., modern Israel) amid this Egyptian-like plague. He envisioned the possibility that all members of his church will be spared, and none will get infected. The first few weeks went by successfully and his optimism grew accordingly. But in less than a year he not only had to abandon his initial plan, but had to perform several CORONA funerals.

         Liberated after the first lockdown, some people flocked to the church to find spiritual consolation. Fully masked, they respectfully attended the open-air religious service separated from their neighbors by two meters of wind and fresh air. At the end of the Mass the crowd piously lined up to receive the Holy Communion. But Communion was served with one and the same silver spoon as the officiating priest believed that the Blessed Sacraments are at odds with all viruses. After this event got some attention from the press, the Orthodox Church publicly apologized and officially renounced the practice.       

A rabbi from Israel openly declared that CORONA represents God’s curse designed to punish the LGBT or gay community. But a few months later, the same rabbi carelessly scratched his nose during a prayer meeting and inadvertently got crowned by millions of viruses. Was this a sign from God that he was part of the invisible LGBT community? I don’t know about that, but I know for sure that it couldn’t be a shorter way to rapidly gain him an international, super-star like mockery fame.

After the vaccine roll-over started, a prominent Romanian Orthodox priest claimed to hold a superior solution: his daily communion has the power to protect him (and everyone else) beyond the effectiveness of any human-made vaccine. However - and here I want to abruptly change to course of the argument - there is no evidence (scientific or otherwise) that a symbol is able to repel a virus, even if that symbol is invested with multiple sacred meanings. As far as I know, any symbol, including religious ones, gets to be just a symbol and throughout time it continues to have the same or an evolving meaning, depending on what various generations decided to ascribe to it. The fallacy comes from clumsily mingling two different levels of analyses in a desperate effort to marry them and force them to take the same wedding picture as bride and groom. But saints and viruses are not to be married. Religious symbols are meant to offer hope, to mold our inner life and boost our motivation for altruism, to positively impact emotions and stimulate gratitude, to talk to our meaning-making and symbolic being that our physical bodies were designed to entertain. Viruses on the other hand couldn’t care less about the symbols we use to grace our churches with or to part-take in religious rituals. All they care about are the biological conditions that allow them to multiply and strive as a species and all they fear are the physical barriers that hinder their progress. Do you see why they are the worst candidates for getting married, and why they don’t like kissing each other? Forcing them to sleep in the same bad will only increase the chance of procreating monsters that that will abate us from getting a straight picture of both our spiritual traditions and our physical world.

Saints and viruses are not to be married not because they are consanguineously related as distant cousins. On the contrary, they are not to be married because they emerged from radically different worlds and house radically different underlying mechanisms, rules, laws and values under their shelters. This doesn’t mean that they have never met, or never touched hands. They did! For example, it is well accepted in psychology that our mind or spirit can influence our body; that generally hopeful people tend to have a stronger immune systems; that adding an extra religious motivation (i.e., considering our bodies as the temple of the Holy Spirit) can effectively contribute to adopting and maintaining healthy behaviors by making us more responsible. But the psycho-somatic relationship is just one of the myriad of influences meant to either strain or uplift our bodies, and not an invincible protective wall against viruses or other foreign invaders. The belief that God reigns in the heavenly realms, lovingly watching and protecting his flock could be helpful and inspiring. But beyond a certain point it can get dirty and entangled in the mud of unrealistic illusions. And our heartfelt wishes expressed in prayers - whether desperate, hopeful, faithful, or casual - are rather dependent on the uncontrollable Will of the Almighty that most of the time gets so sovereign and mysterious that remains impenetrable for our humble minds. That’s why I think saints and viruses are rather distant friends whose spheres of influence only partially overlap; they are acquaintances with different interests and orientations in life, not long time husband and wife. That’s why saints and viruses should neither get married nor be granted a resounding divorce, because their friendly, nonsexual hand-shake represents the mutually fulfilling relationship they both long for.       

Although the spiritual and transcendent values are placed high above and up on the vertical axis while the earthly human ones are placed below and beneath on the horizontal axis, this mere positioning shouldn’t deceive us when it comes to their jurisdiction. The distance between the two spheres resembles rather the haven–earth dichotomy than the dominance of one over the other. Didn’t you ever had the unmistakable impression that transcendent values are placed so high in the sky that they cannot remotely control the earthly details of our below and beneath horizontal axis? Didn’t you ardently wished and prayed for something as if your life depended on it, only to find the circumstances turned in the opposite direction? I did, and it was tremendously frustrating to see that my spiritual efforts to do something (like remote-controlling the mundane events from post of my horizontal axes) appear futile, that the earth seems to be guided by different laws than the haven, that the natural world appears only partially connected to the transcendent. The relationship between the two seems so different from the one cherished by the pinions and cogwheels of a mechanical clock or the gears of a car, where the turns of one wheel are proportionally spinning the other parts in an intimate and coherent move. The relationship seems rather like the loose interactions among the disparate parts of a complex system where discrepant movements and offbeats sometimes play a synchronicity game in a charming and mysterious tango. I am currently and concurrently watching and playing this intriguing tournament, observing in amazement the convoluted mosaic of multiplex movements. But at least for the moment, I am reticent to sail the boat of building fervent generalizations on the narrow basis of singular events. I also trained myself to delay the sweet gratification of manufacturing and erecting immediate theories about how the world works on the basis of my transcendent values and aspirations. I have found enough reasons to believe that saints and viruses are actually only distant, nonsexual friends who enjoy a rather platonic relationship. That’s how they naturally fit together, enjoying fundamentally different jurisdictions. However, their worlds seem to partially and occasionally overlap, and the meeting happens when they decide to respectfully shake hand in spite of the pandemic recommendation to abstain from it or use only the elbow bump.  

Share:

Sunday, May 23, 2021

Life as an attitude 2.0 - My ACT love affaire

 

Last April (04.2020) I had a new “revelation” about the importance of attitudes in life, and I illustrated it with a couple of examples from music, from high quality television shows, and I finally left the readers with a bunch of rhetorical questions about their perspectives toward the multiple facets of the fresh CORONA crises and its impact on our global village (see here The value of attitudes). The truth is that I have always enjoyed witnessing life and its challenges as they unfold, infusing curiosity on my perspectives, and stealing fresh looks from things and people when I wasn’t bored, depressed or anxious. I see life as a tremendously complex show worth attending to, and I was willing to pay a good price in order to have a premium perspective whenever I could afford the associated costs. A bald-bold guy I "meet" through his books during my early 20’s - Stephen Covey – persuaded me that attitudes matter, that having an overall perspective is key in getting oriented in life, that personal and professional evolution could be improved by chosen attitudes that are centered around principles and values. Both psychology and my own Christian spiritual tradition stressed the importance of adopting the “right vantage point”, so I wasn’t completely new to the LIFE AS AN ATTITUDE approach. In fact I coded and recoded my first version (i.e., version 1.0) for more than 20 years by now.

Although I was somehow familiar with the Acceptance and Commitment Therapy (ACT) paradigm, I didn’t really grasp it’s gist from just reading books or even from the in-depth intellectual exploration needed for preparing scientific papers. Therefore, this spring I decided to immerse myself in these waters by taking an online ACT course for psychologists. I thought it would be cool to have another bald-bold guy - Steven Hayes this time - magically appear on my big (almost life size) screen that dominates the space of my home office. Several hundred dollars and a few clicks away I could spend some quality time with him in the comfort of my Romanian home. One of the best parts was the non-conflicting schedules between our busy calendars, as we could have longer or shorter meetings whenever I was able to treat myself with a few ACT training hours. His presence, genuineness, flexible and complex approach, sound scientific base, playful attitudes and valued life perspective reached me with an irresistible and seductive force. I was mesmerized, enchanted, uplifted, and energized by the wealth of implications resulting from just our attitudes-perspectives. How we relate to the universe - be it the internal universe of entangled emotions and thoughts, or the external universe of people, objects, and planets – appeared to me in a fresh new light. The infinite space of consciousness resulted from playfully dancing between different attitudes pushed me in the liberated state of following my values. I irreversibly felt in love with ACT, so much so that I totally embrace it, I wanted to make it my own, to add it to my lifestyle menu so that it will continue to enrich me in the future. Then I realized I was kind of fused with these ideas, so I decided to look at them from different perspectives, to take a break, to allow myself some reflection space. But the post-reflection return was equally liberating, as I found myself in a space where I could not only decide what kind of relationship I want to entertain with ACT, but most importantly, what kind of relationship I want to cultivate with my values, how I can be present in my life, and how I can engage with it guided by what I deem to be important. I don’t know how things will unfold in the future, but my ACT experience certainly enriched my lifestyle menu and upgraded my LIFE AS AN ATTITUDE approach to its 2.0 brand new version. Although the basic components have been successfully installed, there is a long way until they will completely mature and until I will feel comfortable enough with them around because they ended up being impregnated by my personal color palette. However, in my reckless enthusiasm, I started imparting presence, diffusion, and acceptance around; encouraging others in exploring their values, in transcending their conceptualized self, and in engaging with what matters from their newfound and flexible dance of multiple perspectives.               

Share:

Monday, May 3, 2021

Life as a complex unfolding of overlapping and sometimes contradictory events

 It’s May 1st and a while ago the cherry tree in front of my window decided to beautify the garden with hundreds of white, blossomed flowers. By watching it’s enthusiasm for the sunshine you can hardly resist the contagious hope that naturally spreads through its discrete scent. A simple, even absent-minded look towards it could be enough to make you imagine the sap’s hidden joy for invigorating the branches with a new, springtime spirit. However, this year I got to admire the blossomed cherry tree on my way to and from the sky slopes where a handful of passionate skiers continue to take shameless advantage of the surviving snow layers generously bestowed upon us in March and April. Just 15 kilometers away winter seems to reign, despite the sun’s insistence to chase it out. The slopes are not frozen, but there is an unmistakable snow-touch all around the mountain. 
         Last October a friend of mine had an unwanted encounter with a tiny CORONA-virus that forced him to visit the limits of life, to contemplate existence from one of its no-coming-back borders. Looking directly into the void of his possible nonexistence he hanged on for a few days, his body connected with an oxygen mask. During several sleepless nights he came to appreciate not only the value of our taken-for-granted oxygen, but also the value of being intentional and really present. From the simplest, mostly unnoticed details like admiring a tree or a town building that happen to end up on our retina, to the inexpressible need to deeply connect with family members, to reshaping some behaviors so that they match his newly discovered values – he reemerged to life with a different perspective. This uninvited detour that occasioned a personal look into the final nonexistence made him burst back to life with an outrageous courage to exist. At first he wasn’t sure what to make of it, but gradually he managed to process his experience and started to gracefully taste the juicy core of a valued life, becoming a wiser, more loving human being. 
         But CORONA was merciless with others, leaving some families dismantled. Hopeless feelings, disbelief and disorientation hit hard as emotional, practical and financial imbalance is struggled with on a daily basis. Black becomes the dominant emotion engulfing the internal world for weeks and months at a time. Looking around nothing seems to be quite as it used to. Looking around we see other infected victims who manage to recover, while others don’t, leaving behind a never-to-be-filled void. In this bleak, difficult to bear context, one of my courageous friends - who lost her partner to CORONA - gathered her strengths to join a wedding ceremony, the first major event attended without her husband.  
         About two thousand years ago twelve regular Jews followed a strange new teacher who managed to ignite their motivation by sketching in front of their hopes a different, more humane spirituality. At some point they initiated what they imagined to be the most successful presidential campaign of all times, if only He had accepted their offer. Not only He dismissed the idea on the spot discouraging them to ever attempt such insane initiatives, but a couple of years down the road He was arrested, unfairly convicted and killed by the current establishment. Their hopes sank abruptly, absorbed by the endless black hole of the Master’s irreversible death. Three days later the hopeless, grieved and disoriented disciples had the most extraordinary revelation when encountering their resurrected Master and touching His scarred wounds with their fingers. Hope followed despair, and life followed death in the most amazing and unexpected juxtaposition in history.
         The events briefly sketched above have few similarities, but maybe what makes them stand together and not snap apart is that all of them are part of life. Sometimes contradictory events take place in a similar or very close space-time with similar or even the same actors. Paradoxical events overlap or juxtapose in a complex and intricate web design. Spring overlaps with winter and the sunny sky overlaps with the rain. A detour close to the no-coming-back border of death sparks a shameless reemergence to a fuller, more fulfilled life. Tearfully looking at the past after the loss of a partner overlaps with joyfully looking at the future as a new couple celebrates their wedding. The death of their Master that sank the disciples’ hopes in the endless pit of despair occasioned the most stunning resurrection in history. Life itself can be seen as a complex unfolding of contradictory events, overlapping or juxtaposed, a zigzag intertwine of paradoxes with unending stops and beginnings. As adult human being we only get to decide whether we want to be part of it, and present in it, or not. Deciding for the secure noninvolvement gets us closer to the nonexistence and the death we already fear. Deciding for the risky and real life involvement could be both painful and glorious, both heartbreaking and fulfilling. We would like to cross out “painful” and “heartbreaking” and to keep only “glorious” and “fulfilling.” But that is not our choice! We only get to decide whether we want to embrace life – with its overlapping contradictions, with its pains AND glories – or not. All the rest is up to God.          
Share:

Sunday, February 21, 2021

The cacophonies of human cognition: A psychologist’s perspective on cognitive distortions

 

The CORONA crisis – and in fact any other personal or collective crisis for that matter - represents a golden opportunity to notice the disintegrated dance and numerous circus parades animated by human cacophonies and misinterpretations. As humans we have an innate tendency towards distortions, we like them so much, we embrace them to such an extent that they become engrained into and indistinguishable from our nature. Humanity has always entertained a deep connection with cognitive distortions, so deep that we have identified our beings, our lives, our careers, our friends and even our family with them. We are made of flash and blood, neurons and synapses, not of 0 vs. 1 dichotomies. We get animated by emotions, remember or misremember past events, and tend to use personal experiences when interpreting new situations. Which is fine up to a certain point; but the results of our interpretations end up to be, well, idiosyncratic, how else? The mere fact that some of you started skeptical about my abrupt and critical assertions on the ubiquity of cognitive distortions, on the frailty of human interpretations, and on the sheer popularity of various cognitive cacophonies we all easily embrace (and sometimes refuse to let go) only prove that there is some grain of truth in my approach.    

         False beliefs or subjective undeserved trust in unsupported conclusions (the ancient name used for what we now label as cognitive distortions) represents actually quite an old and unresolved issue for humanity. I’ll only briefly mention a few hints that greater minds than mine alluded to during the recorded history. Observing the world and how humans behave in it Aristotle noticed that: "The ignorant strongly affirms his convictions, the scholar doubts his conclusions, and the wise man (the philosopher) reflects on what he sees." Confucius, four centuries BC, believed that "True knowledge comes from knowing the dimension of your ignorance." Charles Bukowski mentioned that the problem with our world is that intelligent people are full of doubts, and others… are full of confidence. You see, the same undeserved trust in unsupported conclusions was noticed long before humans invented the word psychology or came up with more objective methods designed to test apart the truth from the untruth. Nowadays we use the evolving and complex scientific methods for that purpose, and we partially succeeded to put aside some unsupported ideas about us as humans and about our world. But unfortunately, science cannot remove our appetite for cognitive cacophonies that only scream wilder in uncertain situations.  

Underestimating the danger of getting infected with CORONA and/or its possible consequences for your health could be equally damaging as it is overestimating them and being constantly anxious and on guard. Other cognitive cacophonies we uses more often than intended are: jumping to conclusions, disqualify the positives, thinking in black and white terms, mislabeling, expecting to live in a just world (fairness fallacy), to have total control of our life (control fallacies), to exert real change on others (change fallacies), while our decisions are biased (or primed) by unrelated anchors, by recently activated memories, by aversion loss, by the framing of the problem at hand. I’m not going to enter into much detail here regarding each cognitive distortion, but if you are interested I can provide some references.[1] Daniel Kahneman, a well-known professor from Princeton University who was awarded the Nobel Prize in Economics (2002), released a book where he analyses our thinking processes: Thinking fast and slow. Here he mentions that even experts in their field entertain cognitive biases and make errors (which Kahneman finds to be funny). And that’s because subjective confidence, which is closely related to the probability of being correct, is not a judgment, but an emotion. If the explanation or story we made up in our minds seems well-articulated and coherent we can’t help but feel positive about it (it feels right!) and we ascertain higher scores for its confidence. But the problem is that we can come up with coherent stories out of very little information that is in fact unreliable. And the quality of the story (its credibility!) depends little on the quality and quantity of the basic information used to construe it. So we can be confident of our conclusions having little reasons to support this, because confidence represents an unreliable sensor for trusting anything. And if this story about subjective confidence as an emotion is not enough, I could add another argument that relates to how our memory works. It was proven that when we think of past events we don’t just retrieve the information from memory (as a video tape would do), but we rather reconstruct it from the raw materials that are the most accessible for us at that moment, and our reconstructions are, obviously, not accurate. You don’t have to believe me for that thesis, just read Daniel Schacter’s book The Seven Sins of Memory: How the Mind Forgets and Remembers. And just as another example, neuroscientist Daniel J. Levitin described memory as "a puzzle with many missing pieces. We rarely retrieve all the pieces and our brains fill in the missing information with creative guesses, based on experience and patterns of matching. This lead to many unfortunate missrecollections, often accompanied by the stubborn belief that we are recalling accurately. We cling to this missrememberings, storing them to our memory bank incorrectly, and then retrieve them in a still-incorrect form and with a stronger (misplaced) sense of certainty that they are accurate" (see Successful aging Ch. 2 Memory and the sense of "you", p. 33)

So these cacophonic distortions seem to have been part-and-parcel of human cognitive processes long before I was born and will probably continue to be so long after I will stop typing about them. Any attempt to correct-them-all and to be totally-free is such an impossible endeavor that even perfectionistic champions, with little to no tolerance for their ambiguity, end up exhausted and finally surrender to their continuous attacks. That’s because attempts to get free-of-ALL-cognitive-distortions are simply vain and futile. We are not entirely helpless in this fight, that’s true; and we can mend a few cacophonies here and there. We can identify our most common cognitive distortions and try to decatastrophize them, we can differentiate facts from opinions or hypothesis (and eventually test our hypothesis), we can be skeptical about our own conclusions, we can learn to discern and rely on scientific evidence (and not on subjective confidence), and we can understand how culture, education, religion and experience have shaped our world-view. But compared to the sheer number of distortions assaulting us on a daily basis, it’s like one gun-man fighting an entire battalion of Chinese army. If the gun-man is motivated and smart enough, he can put down a few caporals. But the continuous nature of the fight (i.e., our incessant cognitive processes) makes his job unsustainable. While on duty, the gun-man has to eat, sleep, talk to his friends, make love, raise his children, buy groceries, satisfy his hobbies, enjoy the weekend, and go on vacations. Not to mention his frequent attention slips and long boredom intervals while actively watching. And any breaches are immediately speculated by one or more of the cunny cacophonic soldiers or caporals who risk their lives to sneak in and do their filthy job. In time, these soldiers (and sometimes even generals) end up moving inside and having a permanent residence in our minds. That’s how cognitive distortions got so ingrained in the myriad of information processes entertained daily by our brains, representing such a core part of our imperfect cognitions that the only way we can stop-them-all is to stop our thinking process all together. Somber as it may be, if we were to preserve our cognitive functions we have no choice but to accept their less-than-perfect functionality as an inescapable fact of life, and get on with it.  

 



[1] Cognitive distortions: when your brain lies to you - here you have a written description of some cognitive biases and some solutions, and 30 cognitive biases and psychological misjudgments - here you could watch a more comprehensive list of cognitive biases released at the beginning of the CORONA pandemic

Share:

Tuesday, June 16, 2020

Assuming responsibility


Irony represents a powerful weapon, especially when handled with dexterity. After three month of daily extensive media coverage on the imminent CORONA threat, even senior journalist’s highest frustration tolerance limit crashes under Trump’s invulnerability illusions. Yesterday Anderson Cooper reported that experts from the University of Washington estimated about 200.000 US deaths caused by CORONA until October 1. Despite this dire situation some high profile politicians behave as if their gaze got tired of following the invisible virus. Actually one of Trump’s recent spontaneous remarks was: “If we stop testing right now (for CORONA-virus) we will have very few cases, if any...” Such out-of-sight-out-of-mind approach prompted Cooper to ironically wonder whether Trump have surpassed the object permanence stage of development that normal 2 year olds are proudly acquiring. And his answer was that “the president perhaps hasn’t reach that stage (i.e., of object permanence), not at least when it comes to a virus that have claimed 116,000 deaths” only in the US. This biting sarcasm was meant to expose and corrode the president’s “twisted logic”, his failure to grasp the good warning signals testing are meant to bring, and his intention of hiding CORONA under the rug. But is Anderson Cooper’s strategy effective?

     At the beginning of March many tourists had definite plans to relax on various Cruise Ships. For example an Australian couple bought tickets for a local cruise around New Zealand. Despite the depressing CORONA news they supposed it would be safe to embark on their long awaited journey as the authorities approved the trip, the tourist agency seemed ok with it and they were not actually going towards China. If anything was not ok the organizers should announce us, they lightly reasoned, relaying for their go ahead decision on the organizers’ responsibility. However, after just a few days it became obvious that relying solely on Cruise’s responsibility was actually a bad strategy. During the cozy events enjoyed by everyone in the first half of the trip CORONA insidiously rolled up her sleeves and made a big catch, including the husband of our Australian couple. His symptoms were severe, and his unpleasant convalescence was longer than the cruise itself, but he survived. That is probably one of those situations where not thinking with your own mind could triple your losses (with the holiday savings invested in a ruined holiday spend on a virused cruiser that made you sick to the point of life-threatening).

     On June 20 Trump plans to organize an election rally in Tulsa (Oklahoma) where about 19.000 people are invited to spend a few hours indoors listening to their dream candidate and cheering out loud their support. It is an official event and authorities approved it, so most people could lightly reason it should be ok to have republicans from across the US crammed into the same space. This kind of events are so much part and parcel of the American culture and politics that people could not give them up just because an invisible virus decided to stubbornly move around. Plus CORONA represents not news anymore as everyone got accustomed with, and even bored by this obsolete topic. And just a few days before, many cities had multiple days of approved and unapproved protests for social justice and chanted their loud support for the Black Life Matter (BLM) movement. Now it’s time for republicans to cheer up, and make their voices heard, and enjoy the fun, emotional, spontaneous, optimistic, inimitable Trump speeches they craved for. And during those speeches nobody will take CORONA seriously, as this topic will be approached lightly, and optimistically, with the invulnerability approach so energetically put forward by Trump’s prevailing attitude. So there is a good chance that the nasty virus will be looked at differently, as an actually unthreatening inconvenience, at least for that day.  
But CORONA doesn’t really care about US politics, or BLM, or whether she can operate on land in Oklahoma or on the sea near New-Zealand. Her only aim is to have a big catch. So chances are that two weeks down the road some republicans will get infected, and will further share their experience with their friends and family. And in the many weeks before the November election some former Oklahoma rally republicans will be unable to vote because voting is irrelevant for those who inadvertently passed on the other side of life’s threshold. That’s another way in which America is leading the world in terms of CORONA infected cases and fatalities, evening the number of affected Caucasians so as to keep up with the disproportionately large number of black cases occasioned by poverty, and lack of education, an lately by the numerous BLM unrests.    
         
Finally, what still surprise me is how ready and willing some people are to delegate their responsibility to whatever authority they happened to have above. By now everyone on the planet have heard in his language multiple messages about CORONA’s whereabouts and what we should do to avoid meeting her in person. However, if a Cruise company in Australia, or the Republican Party in the US, or the Government in Sweden says that it is OK to have a large meeting, or mingle with random strangers as we normally do, or to enjoy our already paid cruise, there will always be people who show up. Since the event was approved by an authority figure, they lightly reason it must be safe and sound to follow. Plus, they are convinced it’s not a big deal to participate, they are just engaging in normal behaviors that were impossible during the last months and stolen from them. I still can’t approximate how massive a threat must be to make people take it seriously, or whether it is humanly possible for a public event to be announced and not attended. Probably not!


Share:

Sunday, May 31, 2020

When anger overrides fear

Protesting during a pandemic represents a toxic combination with a potentially damaging impact for the society as a whole. However, the not even vaguely veiled dangers of CORONA contamination was literally trampled by the righteous anger tornados stirred by the knee on the neck murder of George Floyd in Minneapolis (May 25, 2020). The video showing Floyd’s last minutes struggle to breathe under the weight of former police officer Derek Chauvin went viral because it deeply touched on our emotions. This preventable death represents another incident where black citizens are overly-subdued by white police officers in the US, adding one more case to the already long history of unresolved issues. Upon seeing such injustice emotions got on fire and released a dynamite-like explosion of reactions. The wildly protesters went out of their way to make themselves heard and use this momentum to express their rage hoping to change something in the justice system. But as anger turned blind, more damage and suffering was inflicted, at least for the moment (i.e., as police or random cars were broken, buildings and stores were set on fire, protesters and police officers were injured, and non-trivial conditions for the flourishing of CORONA’s up-spiral ascent were created).    
      
Authorities could not oppose the protests, and faintly tried to remind citizens about face-masks and social distancing practices. Somehow remote from the mob, a CNN image depicted “A woman wearing a mask protests near the Colorado State Capitol in Denver” as mindful of such ideals. But in the background of the “I can’t breathe” T-shirt woman a large mass of unmindful protesters were not socially distancing and countless other clashes were recorder throughout the US. The crude reality is that when people are enraged it seems improbable to regulate their behaviors by appealing to their rationality or by reminding them of an invisible viral threat. As unfair as George Floyd’s death was, it is likely to cause more damage and death on the short term before it might contribute to the justice system on the long term. Besides the direct damage inflicted to human lives and properties, one additional reason is caused by CORONA’s indifference for how and why her spread is facilitated. Consequently, in two weeks we might see a rise in US infected cases, and in a month more than one additional black coffin conducted to the grave. However, this potentially larger damage prompted by the many individual decisions to take part in the protest could have been prevented if only the righteous anger would have been directed in a different way. But I must admit this is a really, truly hard and difficult to achieve task for the untamed human nature.

O the surface it might seem a sharp contrast between deciding to willingly keep one’s knee on someone’s neck for 8’46” and deciding to rightfully express one’s anger for such an appalling act while discounting the invisible no-death-threat-for-today carried out by a virus. But that’s only on the surface – as one action seem to lead directly to suffering and death of another human being, while the other seem to lead indirectly to similar results for oneself and others, but this time through CORONA’s agency. However, the I-can’t-help-it-but-rightfully-protest attitude, although not likely to incur a comparable degree of accountability, might toxically interact with the pandemic and contribute to the exponential growth of the death toll in the US. But powerful anger overrides fear, and instead of protecting black and white lives in the long term, protesters used the momentum to underline their revolt. In other words, they disregarded the invisible risks and went on for to punish the visible one. Only in one month’s time the protesters, the doctors, and we all would be able to estimate how wise that decision was.             

Share:

Sunday, May 17, 2020

The inadvertent consequences of disruptions


When disruptions hit us, or our family, organization or country, our reactions tend to be negative: we get frustrated, panicky-anxious, discouraged and resentful as we quickly realize that old solutions are useless, known shortcuts are impracticable and normal advancement is partially or totally blocked. So we see ourselves thrown in what we perceive as strange new mess with little (if at all) experience to rely on, facing an uncharted mountainous terrain. Our unpreparedness might be just part of the picture as we soon notice the clumsy movements of the other actors, be them big or small. Uncertainty kicks in as complex causal chains start to shift dramatically out of their normal tracks and make educated predictions seemed closer than ever before to five year olds guessing about nuclear power.

       Despite the undoubtedly negative consequences at all levels (health, economy, policy making, psychological functioning etc.) that we have to wrestle with, disruptions have at least two additional side-effects that we shouldn’t pass over. The first one is related to their capacity to make more transparent (at least temporarily) the internal, usually hidden, underlying mechanisms that sustain the disrupted system. By closely following how it was forced to perform under pressure and in uncertain situations, by watching its crude and spontaneous reactions, by seeing the route it followed when it had to unwillingly deforest the unexplored mountain - the subtle observer can only praise the golden opportunity to complete the image with the missing or dimly colored pieces of the puzzle. This is, in and of itself, a mighty topic I am certainly tempted to explore further (most probably in another post).

      The second side-effect of disruptions, that I am willing to chase now, is related to their capacity interrupt and disturb our internal world. The mere fact that old tracks turn unusable overnight urges us to suddenly stop, take a deep look at the new chaos, and devise something. But interestingly enough, the stopping and reevaluating moment could have consequences that might reverberate beyond the mere “what shell I do now?” unknown. Such suspended discontinuities, at least for those inclined to question the philosophical underpinnings of their behavior, might occasion a deeper analysis of what animates them (or their organization, the health system, the government) to engage in these behaviors, of why and how these actions were carried out in the first place. These unwelcomed and resented interruptions could actually make us pay renew attention, could bring a fresh perspective, could make some things appear sharper, and make us notice what previously stayed unnoticed. We might have the chance to listen the muted hums of deeply hidden personal wishes, to get in contact with our values, to reconsider some choices that were half-consciously reiterated hundreds of times during the loud noise of everyday live music.  

      Looking back two months ago, when the CORONA crisis had just started, for a moment I had the impression that my usually buzzing academic world - that continually demanded something of me - had suddenly stopped, and I was literally unable to interact with it (i.e., as the regular face-to-face classes were suspended). It was a moment of pure silence, when the whole world seemed suspended, smoothly floating in a foreign space, with just the void surrounding me from all over. And for a split second I subjectively had a powerful impression that I was totally free in that floating space, unbound by any straps, disengaged from everything except my passions, absolutely free to direct my whole mind towards activities that makes me reverberate with truly vital tonalities. It was during that moment that I’ve been in contact with my deep values whose hum was continuously blocked by the buzzing noises and the incessant external demands once essential for my professional development. It was during that moment that I realized how limiting the attached straps were for my intellectual freedom and for my creativity that could not take hold of my entire mind due, mainly, to the lack of psychological space. It was during that moment that I decided to carve in my program more writing time, to devote myself towards contemplating the fresh new images unintentionally revealed by CORONA’s multiple disruptions, to welcome and even entice creativity, to express myself courageously.  

      Besides being disheartening and forcing the stop and reflect stage, disruptions pressure us to take actions and push things forward, sometimes in entirely new conditions. After the denial is surpassed and the initial shock absorbed, after the earth rotates around its axis for a few uneasy nights, the unmistakable feeling that something significant has shifted willy-nilly pushes us to change gears if we want to rise up to the challenge. Unsure whether we can make even one step forward we make our first moves in a state of agitation, apprehensive of what might happen. Around us things look messy and we are not entirely sure how to proceed but it’s overwhelmingly evident that decisions have to be made and actions have to be taken. And the very interaction between the pressure to solve a problem and the messiness around (present in the environment or in our own minds or both) has the potential to spur creativity, as Tim Harford persuasively argues in his book. Baffled and resentful, we find ourselves in the uncomfortable position to cope with the unexpected. And since most memories fall short when it comes to solving new problems in unfamiliar circumstances we knock at the door of creativity hoping for some get-around ideas, or at least some plausible and handy hypotheses. We became suddenly ready and willing to step out of our comfortable shoes, to try new things, to tolerate unfamiliarity, and to spend more time solving problems. And such openness, that we didn’t even bother to greet before the crisis or to spend one evening per month with, was actually a by-product of the disruptive event per se. But Tim Harford mentions in his talk on the Importance of Being Messy that the alertness occasioned by taking an unprecedented rout, and sometimes by engaging in a longer adventure to explore the unknown, can actually bring the extra bit of energy needed for the creative work.               

      Finally, I am not arguing that disruptions are good and they should definitely get an invitation to the ball. I am not even arguing that they always lead to philosophical awakenings, or improve our creativity, or help us better understand the underlying mechanisms of the disrupted system. I am just arguing that disruptions primarily disrupt, and oftentimes bring unredeemable damages and lose. And that’s their main job! However, by forcing us to act differently they also have some inadvertent potentialities that some of us might take advantage of. And I don’t know what your reactions to CORONA’s multilevel disruptions were, but mine incorporated multiple concerns, and worries, and frustrations. But I was also surprised by an unexpected gift box I received with a word twisting game inside. The instructions were to use some word twists as a way to contribute to the up scaling of my neighbors coping strategies. And you might remember, from a previous post, that among my neighbors I counted the teenage Vietnamese girl who just learned English and the Peruvian middle age man who recently got divorced. And interestingly enough, playing around with the word game somehow captured my attention to the point of underestimating how fast a Sunday can pass while writing.     

Share:

Saturday, April 25, 2020

The wind and the cherry tree



I was reading in my studio during one spring weekend day trying to delight myself with the oftentimes fascinating perspectives of other brilliant minds. And during one brief pause my accidental glance on the window caught the unannounced white petals parade enacted by the playful interaction between the wind and a nearby cherry tree. My buzzing mind abandoned for a moment all previous activities and let itself be absorbed by the splendors unfolding before my eyes. During that mindful moment I realized how wastefully generous the nature is when offering such free confetti productions, with no previous warnings or advertising. Neither the wind choreographer nor the cherry tree petal dancers seemed to care even for a bit whether their unique show is recorded or not, or whether someone, anyone, is paying attention. God know how many times I’ve missed their beautiful acts during my busy days while caught up in my cluttered program. But with or without bystanders, the wind and the cherry tree are naturally enjoying their daily interactions being animated exclusively by intrinsic motivations, with no thoughts whatsoever about anything that would vaguely resemble performance anxiety. They carry on with their lives and offer every spring, to anyone who cares watching, their wastefully beautiful charades of wedding like confetti entertainment. And probably that’s why such candid moments, with their magical appeal, can evoke in those attending a real cascade of emotions like joy, and gratitude, and awe. If we care to notice, nature offers us such beautifully brief mementos that, despite what happen around and inwards, hope still survives.         

Email: bogdan.tulbure@e-uvt.ro
bogdan-tudor-tulbure.blogspot.com



Share:

Tuesday, April 21, 2020

Hypothesis for CORONA’s origin



When faced with uncertainty and unpredictability we naturally struggle to fill in the void with plausible explanations. Making sense of what we see and coming up with credible theories represent a legitimate attempt to better orient ourselves in the new environment. The increasing number of CORONA infections and deaths, the massive disruption for our daily life and the economy made us fill in the unknown with different theories. However, when competing explanations fight for shedding light into the same mechanisms (i.e., the natural or artificial nature of a virus), only one takes the gold medal at the final ceremony.   
     Here I’ll try to briefly tackle an important question using a rather factual and scientific approach: What is the origin of CORONA? Where was she born in the first place? The buzzing rumors on this hot topic goes from being man-made to having a natural origin, from arising in China or elsewhere (US?), from being intentionally or accidentally transmitted to humans and wide spread. I’ll try to objectively present some facts and let you decide for yourself about your favorite hypothesis. Anyhow, experts are not surprised to see so many hypotheses flourish in this context, as a close source to the White House coronavirus task force mentioned that "every time there is an outbreak someone proposes that the virus or other pathogen came out of a lab" including the US intelligence.   
     Synthetizing the discourse regarding the viruses’ origin I found four main hypotheses that seem to circulate widely:
1) CORONA was manufactured in the lab as part of the Chinese bioweapon program,
2) CORONA was brought to China by the US Army during the Military Games held in Wuhan (October 2019),
3) CORONA (accidentally) leaked from one of the Research Labs in the Wuhan area and spread to the densely populated mainland China,
4) CORONA jumped from bats to humans (probably mediated by another animal) at one of Wuhan’s wet-markets, where wild animals from across the globe were kept in insalubrious conditions.       
     For each hypothesis I’ll present the facts using a chronological order and my best scientific–impartial-objective mode and let you analyze the evidence in a separate post. Finally, I’d like to emphasize that my approach is apolitical and biased towards favoring only what I consider solid scientific data, as I am motivated by no additional interests besides my quest for understanding and making sense of what happens with our world.   


Share:

Sunday, April 19, 2020

The value of attitudes


Attitudes possess a hidden power to shape and color the melodic and even atonal notes of our lives in most circumstances we have to face throughout the journey. They can set a starting point for what may come later or change the action’s course in the same way as a musical key sets the tone (or pitch) for the notes that unfold on its portative. And my feeble musical allusions are only meant to introduce a recent interaction I had with a dear violinist friend during a leisure talk on a Saturday afternoon. We were discussing about how the same melody can be interpreted differently according to the performer’s attitude. And as our host had a violin at hand, she just exemplified how the same Beethovenian piece can be interpreted with the heavy touch of Johannes Brahms, with the loose flexibility of gypsy fiddlers, and with the original attitude of Ludwig van Beethoven himself. At the end of the brief impromptu concerto all of us were quite struck by the unexpected diversity hidden in the same musical architecture if approached from different perspectives. The immediate juxtaposition of these divergent attitudes, with the various emotions and distinct paths they alluded to, made them stand apart even more.

        The importance and contagious nature of attitudes becomes also apparent during high quality interviews professional journalists conduct. I am talking about the much appreciated experts journalists who are familiar with their field, and spend quality time investigating the details of the discussed topic. In Romania we have a show called “The professionals” where Eugenia Vodă - a movie critic and TV producer - invites different personalities for extensive and oftentimes philosophical interviews about their careers. Her show stayed in top for years as she invited many people, from artists to soccer players, to unveil the details of their path. And during all this time her fascination for the individuals’ achievements, and creativity, and obstacles, and hidden hard work, and unexpected moves never drained. She managed to set a unique tone for her quality productions because her questions were inspired by an authentic enchantment for high performers. And the fascination conveyed by her tone and attitude was nearly always transferred to the interviewee who danced with her every question. I suppose she took advantage of the implicit flattering message send by taking such a profound interest in the details of one’s career or one’s life as a whole. Nevertheless, her attitude was certainly the main source of inspiration for her questions that set the stage for each hour long interview; and by aggregation, for her lifelong journey. That’s just one more example of how a healthy and productive attitude can sets the tone for the notes that unfold on its portative.

          I could elaborate at infinitum about the key impact attitudes have in setting or changing the course of the journey, but I will save this option for latter. Now I just want to leave you with a challenge and some spear time for personal reflections. And there it is: What’s your general attitude towards the CORONA unexpected visit? Are you baffled by the economic impact of the virus and tend to be more sensible to these aspects? Do you have strong opinions about how politicians should manage this complex crisis and tend to launch predictions about the effectiveness of the world leaders’ strategies? Was your scientific curiosity stimulated and you follow the progress of the medical/scientific community? Are you more concerned about the psychological aftereffects and try to prevent them from crippling your family or business? Are you looking for or just started to take advantage of the new opportunities for your business or scientific career or artistic productions? Are you considering how the medical system could be reformed for both practitioners and scientists? Do you see the fragility of human life from a different (broader and wiser) perspective now that you/someone close/your country was affected by CORONA’s unforgiving sting? Do you tend to use this time for deeper introspections regarding true values and the core directions of the life you’d like to pursue after the virus will be unequivocally defeated? What are your attitudes? And how would you like them to set the tone for the notes ready to unfold on your portative after the restart?                   
      
Share:

Sunday, April 12, 2020

Could the second joy be happier for you too?

I’ve been told that my texts seem too dense for some readers, with hidden meanings remaining mute at first glance. Probably some of the unexpected moves, abrupt comparisons, sudden changes and wired associations fancied by my excited neurons preclude the normal predictions in an unanticipated fashion. I do apologize for forcing you to hike into such a dense tropical forest of metaphors instead of graciously inviting you to take a nice walk on a sunny beach during a quiet afternoon. But I am not entirely responsible for this. CORONA initiated this global movement and made us deforest new territories overnight, and at least in my case the terrain was uneven, and rough, and bumpy. And from my stay-home-in-confinement I troubled myself with looking at other people to see how they are coping, and then added other institutions and businesses, and whole industries, and finally entire countries. The disturbing and unsettling show that resulted was so full of false notes, clumsy movements and such an amazing series of cacophonies that I couldn’t retain any doubts that we were totally unprepared for this challenge. And my emotions couldn’t just stay cool and remain calm, but instead started to bump around, and excite my neurons, and clashed with my logical thinking to such a degree that my only way out was to reduce the pressure by letting some of them dance on the keyboard. I also tried vigorous physical movements as a cool down strategy, but sport was only a temporary relief. So I decided to let them out as they came, and figured it’s better to have no interference whatsoever with the metaphor concentration they independently decide to go for.

However, I dare offer some unsolicited advice despite the risk of being redundantly behind the already considered possibilities you thought about from the very beginning. If you simply don’t like such convoluted texts, find unpleasant the tropical forest hikes, and repeatedly scratched your legs with the uncut branches, just drop your backpack and go back to the other pleasant stuff that can satisfy your taste better. For those who do like the hikes but find the tropical forest too dense, the tempo to fast, or the metaphors too tropical – there are alternative solutions. You could just go slower and take your time to smell the flowers and notice the shy ladybug hidden under the third leaf (on the back of it, I mean!). Animated by a curiosity that rivals National Geographic experts, I’ve sketched (even if only with my crayons and pastels) some rare tropical species using figurative language just for your pleasure. And if you find these hikes fun you could take the same route twice. I promise you’ll not get bored during your second trip because I’ll impart with you some of the scenery you’ve missed during the first adventure due to the complicated landscape and the sudden flight of that colorful parrot that captured your attention the first time around. I know time is an expensive commodity, and not everyone can afford it, but it might be wiser to take one hike and fully enjoy it, than perspire 20 minutes because you wanted to pack four hikes in the same box, only to retain the general idea and simultaneously guilty your consciousness for not working hard enough or for stealing 1200 seconds from your family.

If you hypothesized that going slower and taking the same hike twice is not bare theoretical talk but imparting from personal experience, I must congratulate you for having such an astute intuition. The slower second hikes I decided to delight myself with as a sign of appreciation for the intellectual ornaments of ideas fancied by some authors were oftentimes sweeter and more fruitful for me. I took the risk of going deeper into the forest and fondle with their wild cats until they surrendered and behaved almost as domestic animals. And at least for me those pleasures got closer and sometimes beyond the point of experiencing an intellectual orgasm. It’s true that by following this strategy I got to see fewer sceneries, hike on fewer mountain paths and acquainted with fewer intellectual partners. But I value deep intimacy way above sheer numbers, so it would take a long time for someone to persuade me out of this. But I am fully aware that the world is diverse not only in terms of colors and races, but even more so in terms of reading preferences. My humble intention was just to make you contemplate the slower and/or repeated hike strategy and eventually try it once to see how it feels. At any rate, these days diversity lovers are really happy as they can enjoy an almost endless number of hikes and sceneries, be them real or virtual.   

This morning I simply remembered an old saying from Proverbs: “If you find honey, eat just enough, too much of it, and you will vomit.” (Prov. 25:16, NIV). And my brain coupled it with the complaints from some readers, so I thought you might also benefit from it (but even if I am plain wrong, I can still look myself in the mirror with no guilt). And when things will get back to normal, I might take the chance to impart with you less convoluted text designs as I hope to regain my pleasure for long and relaxed walks on the beach during quiet afternoons.   


Disclaimer: I just hope you will find charming when I spill over the limits of my English as a second language.



Note: If you happen to be a journalist and think that every now and then I could contribute to the success of your publication, be bold and came up with a good offer. However, bear in mind that I only write about topics I deeply care, so let me drive the roller-coaster.


Share:

Saturday, April 11, 2020

Brief guide against baloney theories


I’ve argued in another post that our CORONA-invaded world is currently in suspension. That leaves our bodies, our home office, the lamp and a bunch of unanswered questions to freely float in a zero-gravity field we couldn’t even imagine last month. We are not used to tolerate such a massive amount of uncertainties, and we really hunger for some solid and sound assurances that could help us navigate through this unexpected new normal. We struggle to get answers, to find some unmovable anchors, but they seem to elude us. To satisfy their ruthless hunger for robust beliefs some people resorted to shortcuts, rapidly sketched a theory mascot, swelled it with warm air and hanged with both hands on it. It’s better to have something than nothing, they encourage themselves. Understanding that complex problems need complex solutions, other people try to tolerate the unknown, to carefully look for facts, to launch and test hypothesis and don’t feel less about themselves when acknowledging the limits of their expertise. The truth is that we are frantically searching, trying to understand the many aspects of this crisis, but we just don’t know all the answers yes. If we are serious about it, we better tolerate these uncomfortable uncertainties now; invest our time in exploring the facts, use tentative language for our hypothesis, and forget all about our love affair with certainty. The world has changed dramatically and more surprises will pop up from under the horizon line as the earth revolves each day, so endorsing an attitude of expectancy and apprehension seems wise. Now it’s time to embrace uncertainty, and have a bath in the see of unknown. But as you probably noticed, not everybody likes this swim. And such unstable and unpredictable environment, where suspended questions float unattended in space, represents a perfectly fertile ground for the blossoming of conspiracy theories and apocalyptic speculations.
In February 2020, when China was struggling to fight CORONA, popular conspiracy theories claimed that the US must be hidden behind the scene. And the story that almost went out of print was that Americans got envious for the Chinese economic growths, so they “accidentally” released the virus in Wuhan. And China’s recession was simply history. In March 2020, when China was out of top 5 countries on both total number of infected cases and total number of deaths, the conspirators changed abruptly their discourse. They claimed that actually China is behind the scene, and to augment the plausibility of their newly fetched theory, proposed a play-like scenario. In scene one: the EU and US companies based in China had to stop production due to the crisis, and consequently their value on the stock market dropped. In scene two: Wuhan is in lock down, over 80.000 cases and 3.000 deaths are registered countrywide, but miraculously Shanghai and Beijing - the Chinese economic and political capitals – remain virtually untouched by the virus. In scene three: China redresses rapidly and starts purchasing at a lower price the EU/US companies based there. And such reliable theories – that peaked at the level of unmovable convictions and were generously shared on social media - were made up in just a few minutes after seeing a couple of videos on YouTube. Wouldn’t it have been better for these guys to replace their firm convictions with a hypothesis-oriented approach, to better look for the facts, and to postpone jumping in unknown waters for the sake of keeping intact their neck vertebras?
There is another group who made a personal mission from carefully watching the end of the world scenarios. They are familiar with the Bible and can easily cite many Revelation verses that, in their view, can be reliably linked to the current societal challenges. And the events occasioned by the CORONA crisis represent just the perfect context for unleashing their apocalyptic projections and fears. They are already shouting out loud “The end of the world is here!” and direct our attention to Bill Gates prophecies on the imminent dangers of epidemics, as if the predictions of computerized models have anything to do with divine revelations. They honestly want to be involved in the saving business and lean towards using all their ammunition now, before it’s too late for the world to hear. However, what they tend to ignore is that a sanitary crises, with all its economic and political consequences, could be just a bump in the world history and not the final 100 meter World Olympic race. Their low tolerance for ambiguity and previous religious distortions made them amenable to quickly embrace and disseminate unsupported conclusions. Wouldn’t it have been better for them to simply use tentative language, acknowledge their apprehension and embrace the present unknown more peacefully? Wouldn’t it have been better to tentatively ask rhetorical questions about the end (either of the entire world or of our individual lives), or allude to some difficult to solve challenges around searching for what’s really valuable in life?  
These are only two examples for how proclaiming hasty reached conclusions before the game is over could end up as a hugely effective way to attract shame. If the first conspiracy theory proponents would have hesitated only a few weeks with their launch, they would have had the chance to witness how Donald’s Trump undeterred optimism got unmercifully trumped by CORONA. If US were behind the scheme as they hypothesized, how come they pay the largest bill in terms of infected cases, death toll and economic loss?  And how serious will the world take the next message of those who spend all their ammunition with lancing firmly believed apocalyptic scenarios that run the risk of remaining children imaginative stories? Well, no more serious that the “Help! The wolf is near!” jokes we all laughed about. Do you see now why it’s not wise to bypass the hard and time-consuming work of being serious grounded in facts before launching your theory?
In times of uncertainty we are forced to exercise our muscle of frustration tolerance, whether we are enthusiastic about it or not. If the strengths of looking the void in the eye seems hidden from you, and the need to have an explanation now (and not next month) overpowers your tolerance of uncertainty, then go buy those cheap conspiracy or apocalyptic inspired theories. But remember that cheap theories resemble cheap clothing. They both tend to wear off quite fast, and in no time your friends will easily see through such a rag your deficits of vitamin D on your un-tanned skin. What’s that? Oh, you stay home and nobody except your family can see your clothing for the moment. But I was referring to the conspiracy/apocalyptic outfit you wore (are still wearing?) on social media and all the selfies you posted on your second life account hoping to get un unprecedented number of likes.
It’s true that this crisis massively restructured our business as usual, and the ball is still rolling, and we don’t see the end of the valley yet. It’s true that we simply don’t know how the governments might react if CORONA decides to increase her death toll rate to 10 or 20%. It’s true that it might be unwise to discard as phantasmagoric some hypothesis before really checking the underlying facts and arguments (and I mean checking the facts and arguments up to the limit of perfectionism but not beyond that point!). It’s true that it’s wise to prepare, and be on guard, and not relax prematurely as “in this world something always does go wrong … and the unexpected does happen – regularly.”[1] It’s true that now it’s a time to be apprehensive and consider – that is think deeply about – your next jump. But don’t jump just yet!
Finally, I was insistently advised by my consciousness to release a short list of strategies that could be freely used by those who want to save some of their credit for the next face-to-face meeting with colleagues and neighbors. So unless you have accepted Albert Ellis’s shame attacking challenge (i.e., when clients perform harmless but intentionally shameful behavior in public as a way to increase their tolerance for negative emotions), try following these 7 warning signs:
What appears today as solid theory tomorrow might be proven wrong!
Be open to all possible hypotheses but look for the hard-proven facts!
If you care for the value of your money don’t buy cheap stuff!
Jump only after checking the depth of the pond!
For the moment use tentative language!
And keep some credits for later!

Disclaimer: I just hope you will find charming when I spill over the limits of my English as a second language.

Note: If you happen to be a journalist and think that every now and then I could contribute to the success of your publication, be bold and came up with a good offer. However, bear in mind that I only write about topics I deeply care, so let me drive the roller-coaster.

Email: Bogdan.Tulbure@e-uvt.ro

[1] Robert Farrar Capon (2002) Kingdom, Grace, Judgment, William B Eerdmans Publishing Co Michigan/Cambridge

Share:

Friday, April 10, 2020

A world in suspension

In our day and age ideas can bounce from one brain to the next continent in seconds due to our loved-hated technology. Let me illustrate, using the six degree of separation framework, how an idea bounced to me from a previously unknown person. For this story I need to activate only four out of the six degrees of separation. In one of my longer than one hour phone talk with a dear Romanian friend he mentioned how one of his American friends had an insight upon seeing the world suddenly halt. She just applied David’s Peat creative suspension idea to the entire world and let the silence do the rest of the magic. The powerful image suddenly created by my mind while talking to my friend made me pause to acknowledge its appeal. Then I asked him to ask her for the copyright. They both said David Peat is actually guilty for launching the idea, and hypothesized he would have approved my initiative of using it. Anyhow, during this process I realized that amid the CORONA crisis I am willing to ride any horse I can get a hold on, as long as it doesn’t throw me off its back for my insistence of playing around. And now let me show you how I tamed Peat’s suspension horse and where it leaded me, once it got used with carrying an additional 80kg burden who took the role of directing his gaze and ride.
What attracted me to the “suspension” idea was the richness and wealth of meaning incorporated by this one word, and how many of them are relevant to the world (in general) and to our CORONA crisis time (in particular). So let’s start smooth with the first general meaning suspension integrates. Seen from the far-away space our planet appears to float in space, suspended only by the invisible gravity the sun exercises to keep it on the orbit. If we click on the zoom-out button one more time, the Milky Way also appears to be suspended in space and afloat. And the mega zoom-out third click gets us to see the whole Universe as suspended in the surrounding infinite space. End of signal coverage, so we have to stop here. One last comment: I am aware that such a Galileo-old universal truth was around before any viruses came up with the idea to freely hitch-hike our planes, trains and cars for their unwelcomed tour around world. But I took the chance to take you on this journey hoping that such a visit would be refreshing. Now don’t forget to put on your parachute, we will be landing back to our CORONA invaded world.
The second meaning of suspension is related to the tranquility that abruptly engulfed the loudly noises that use to assault our senses on a daily basis. CORONA persuaded authorities to suspend all our unessential hectic physical movements, jumps, crazy social gatherings and face-to-face activities. We obviously had different reactions to it, but some (like the American friend of my friend) could not hide their awe upon seeing that what was previously considered absolute musts could be out of the picture in a matter of days. And another equally powerful realization was that, if the situation so requires, we can actually survive without attending the insane rock concerts, club parties, and other fun but unnecessary noises we tend to surround ourselves with as a way to escape the daily demons and dance with the weekend ones. With our physical movements severely restricted - a long, quiet, unprecedented silence sovereignly took over and offered us an unsolicited but solid time for reflections. For art and symphony lovers, those who were blessed with a beyond average sensibility, the seer silence hit a surprisingly inspiring note from the opening mute melody. So they kept quiet and listened to this peaceful and unusual concert of mostly natural notes. Probably such a planetary performance would have made even John Cage, who composed his 4’33’’ no sound music piece in 1952, envious for not going bigger.      
The third meaning of suspension is rather telluric and deeply related to the sanitary, economic, and societal implications of this invasion. Since the world as we knew it was shuttered, and exists no longer, we long for getting our stability back. With old assurances vanished, we wait in tension to see how things will turn over. We have dozens of suspended questions like: “What are the long term consequences for those who recovered, if any?”; “Would my grandma survive through?”; “What is the origin of this virus?”; “Will I know that cough in the near future (for those who didn’t already)?”; “If I’ll get it, how severe will that be?”; “Will my business be able to recover? If YES, at what costs? If NO, what shell I do?”; “Should I risk changing my job to take advantage of the new business opportunities?”; “How big a price-tag governments (and we all) will finally have to pay for being unprepared to meet this pandemic?”; “When will we hug our friends, enjoy big weddings, go to the Carnival in Venice, and attend international conferences again?”; “How will this crisis affect our country and society as a whole?” Hoping to quiet this suspense we got addicted to the news, widely exchange messages on social media, desperately look for what science has to say, and anxiously inspect future economic prospects that seem worth contemplating. But for the moment almost everyone is left with one option: to exercise, more or less enthusiastically, the muscles of frustration tolerance while desperately trying to avoid the total medical and economic collapse. And we just wish this nightmare suspense will end soon and somehow happy.
The forth meaning for suspension is related to the researchers who frantically investigate the problems using different approaches, hoping to hit a potentially effective treatment and a scalable vaccine. However, my sense is that they are currently in the first stage of the creative resolution, where accumulating detailed knowledge on the problem and trying different strategies is the main focus. For example treatment efforts strategies tackle the problem from dissimilar angles trying to: (1) block the receptors CORONA uses to enter the host cell, or (2) block the machinery of the virus multiplication, or (3) block the repackaging of the virus once into the cell, or (4) kill/dissolve the virus itself (see The science behind CORONA-virus). In terms of vaccines, scientists were able to come up with 115 candidates, out of which 78 were confirmed as active and 5 are in an advanced stage of research (according to a recent article from Nature - The COVID-19 vaccine  development  landscape; April 8, 2020). However, at the moment we just don’t know what works medically and also has the scalable potential to get us out of the houses again. And we might just end up with a scientist who, after months of relentless Sisyphean efforts, decides to take the only flight to Malta and simply have a break. And while waiting for the third canceled flight back, his fresh mind that suspended all activities for a week, might just have a brilliant idea. Actually the whole planet waits in suspense for such a creative suspension to happen.
Finally, the fifth meaning of suspension that I want to leave you with comes from the old Jewish tradition of Sabbatical time. Jews were instructed, according to the Torah, not only to keep the seventh day holy, but to offer nature a regenerative season every sevenths year. Nowadays US universities hijacked this concept and offered tenured faculty a sabbatical leave for intellectual regeneration after a seven year chunk of normal teaching. Honestly, I wish all universities (including mine!) would have incorporated such a refreshing strategy into their personnel policy. But despite working for a non-sabbatical leave university; through a combination of luck, courage and perseverance; I managed to savor the benefits of such a regenerative time during my Fulbright year at the University of Virginia, US. So I know from experience the benedictions of having an entire year just to renew your perspectives, to steer your creativity, and fuel fresh motivation into your tank for trying new adventures. That now 12 years old sabbatical time remains among the top three high times of my life.
With the university leave parenthetical digression aside, we have to admit that CORONA’s threat convinced entire businesses, and industries, and whole countries to take a forced sabbatical time. Only under a severe death threat we bitterly capitulated into giving the planet a break, and reducing air pollution, and giving spring the right to blossom in a quieter, more serene space. Holding grudges we retreated in our shelters while cherry trees bloom, and California grapefruits remain unfamiliar with jet sounds and traffic-jam after effects. Have it ever occur to you that such a sabbatical time (ruthlessly stolen from our businesses, I know!) was actually so much cherished by nature that plants from around the world signed up to express their joy in a huge universal choir concert? Did you notice that forests unions mobilized everyone to increase their processing production for CO2 excesses, knowing well that this generation of sequoia trees may not live long enough to see a similar opportunity? I bet you didn’t! And if you managed to stay out of reach for the buzzing environmentalists’ messages, I just want to let you know that their wildest dreams could not even fancy such a long sabbatical celebration. Their business as usual was to convince 10% of the drivers to use their bikes for two days in a row. But the planet’s sabbatical suspension made them experience such a profound happiness that they just couldn’t stop smiling not only for a day, but for many weeks at a time. And finally, despite my non affiliation with the green party, I hope to make that smile contagious and leave you peacefully admiring the happy, unpolluted magnolia in your garden.

P.S. I am fully aware that not even savvy psychologists could do anything to escape the inevitable distortions of overgeneralizations. While for many of us the world might be in suspension, for first line responders - like the medical and military personnel, politicians faced to suddenly manage comatose countries, protective equipment producers, scientist frantically searching for vaccines and some others – the world seem more like a chaotic nuclear accelerator. Their minds enjoys the suspension silence only unconsciously during the much needed sleep recharge time when surprised by the stillness of the normal rush hours.
 Disclaimer: I just hope you will find charming when I spill over the limits of my English as a second language.
Note: If you happen to be a journalist and think that every now and then I could contribute to the success of your publication, be bold and came up with a good offer. However, bear in mind that I only write about topics I deeply care, so let me drive the roller-coaster.

Email: Bogdan.Tulbure@e-uvt.ro





                                                                

Share: